The 25 Best Horror Anthology Movies of All Time

Movies Lists horror movies
Share Tweet Submit Pin
The 25 Best Horror Anthology Movies of All Time

Although the concept of “anthology” films could be said to date back as far as D.W. Griffith’s Intolerance in 1916, the storytelling device has always found a natural bedfellow with the horror genre. Perhaps it approximates oral tradition—different stories told by different speakers, gathered around a campfire or sharing a cabin on a dark and stormy night. Horror stories, often simplistic and straightforward by nature, can function well as bite-sized morsels of fright. Anthologies, therefore, make room within the genre for tales that could never have supported feature-length films (although particularly successful anthology segments may very well receive that treatment).

Of course, the trick with horror anthologies is maintaining any sense of consistency. This is particularly difficult as the number of entries rises in any given anthology—three to five often seems to be the sweet spot, while anthologies with a few dozen stories (such as The ABCs of Death) tend to be frustrating just as often as they’re effective. The holy grail is the anthology that does everything well, both in its individual stories and framing device, with each story somehow contributing to the whole.

Here, then, is a list that features some of the genre’s most inspired anthology entries, spanning a period of nearly 75 years. You’re guaranteed to find something that will put you in the Halloween spirit, all year round.


25. The House That Dripped Blood (1971)
Director: Peter Duffell

house-that-dripped-blood-inset.jpg

If the output of British film studio Amicus Productions usually lacked the refinement and grandeur of Hammer’s horror films, they always seemed to make up for it with cheeky, good-natured charm. Their anthology horror films, such as Dr. Terror’s House of Horrors, have a disarmingly simple quality to them—less the stately, stuffy gothic horror of Hammer, and more a continuation of the violent, ironic and comical horror stories seen in American E.C. Comics (Vault of Horror or Tales From the Crypt). The House That Dripped Blood is one of those vintage anthologies, centered around a cursed house continuously inherited by new tenants—which is to say, victims. Its tales are silly and basic, but it’s buoyed by a strong cast of familiar British faces, from the duo of Peter Cushing and Christopher Lee (they’re in different stories, sadly) to Raiders of the Lost Ark’s Denholm Elliott and consummate Hammer buxom beauty Ingrid Pitt. It’s the perfect film for a jovial, Halloween party atmosphere—vintage spooky, but never truly disturbing. —Jim Vorel


24. The Theatre Bizarre (2011)
Directors: Douglas Buck, Buddy Giovinazzo, David Gregory, Karim Hussain, Tom Savini, Richard Stanley, Jeremy Kasten

theatre-bizarre-udo-kier-inset.jpg

The Theatre Bizarre is an odd case for horror anthologies: The names you’re likely paying admission to see ultimately don’t end up being the film’s highlights. The likes of Tom Savini and Richard Stanley are the hooks for this grand guignol-themed take on the anthology structure, but their segments are both loosely structured and narratively inert. More interesting is the framing device itself, which sees a young woman lured into an abandoned theater, where a puppet (played by none other than Udo Kier) tells her stories as the two begin to metamorphosize. The film is also odd for the fact that its most acclaimed segment, “The Accident,” is really more of a melodrama than a horror short, out of place with the rest of the film while simultaneously delivering an emotionally powerful tale. —Jim Vorel


23. Trilogy of Terror (1975)
Director: Dan Curtis

trilogy-of-terror-inset.jpg

Many horror anthologies, especially older ones, are known to modern audiences specifically for a single entry, and this is especially the case in Trilogy of Terror, which first aired on ABC in March of 1975. Although all three segments star actress Karen Black and are based on the stories of Richard Matheson, it’s “Amelia” that captivated audiences: a quirky tale about a young woman who lives alone in a high-rise apartment, where she is menaced by an African “Zuni fetish doll” that magically comes to life wielding a spear and ludicrously large knife. It’s a silly, slavering, racially questionable antagonist, but its design is also surprisingly unnerving—although it’s hard to take the story seriously with Black’s over-the-top performance. The other two parts of this particular anthology are competent but less zany, mostly relying on Black’s sex appeal. “Amelia” remains the highlight, in a cheesily ’70s sort of way. —Jim Vorel


22. Ghost Stories (2017)
Directors: Jeremy Dyson, Andy Nyman

ghost-stories-2018-inset.jpg

Ghost Stories, a joint directorial effort by Andy Nyman and Jeremy Dyson, who adapted the movie from the successful stage play they wrote together back in the late 2000s, isn’t workaday horror hackery. For most of its duration, it’s confidently made, atmospheric and deliciously macabre, a movie that feels like a throwback to yesteryear’s horror without consciously acting like a throwback. Those acquainted with horror history might detect echoes of Nicolas Roeg, Robin Hardy, Michael Powell and the productions of Hammer Films, that beloved British outlet of all things gothic and spooky, but even knowledgeable horror geeks must trace Ghost Stories’ influences on a molecular level. They’re ingrained instead of inserted. It’s the difference between knowing homage and unconscious referencing. Nyman and Dyson love horror. You can sense that love in Ghost Stories’ embrace of classic multi-narrative structure, wrapping a triptych of horror subcategories around the labors of its lonely hero, Professor Phillip Goodman (Nyman), a man who tasks himself with exposing paranormal charlatans. (Think John Edwards, Theresa Caputo, or Ed and Lorraine Warren.) It’s tough being the guy who charges the stage during televised psychic readings to rain on the audience’s parade, but that’s Goodman’s life. Then he gets a letter from Charles Cameron, a famed paranormal investigator and Goodman’s boyhood idol. Now decrepit and living alone in a van by the ocean, Cameron challenges Goodman to explain three supernatural cases he couldn’t solve himself. We’re off to the races, but we always come back to sad sack Goodman, who throughout his investigations can’t help noticing weird phenomena in between visiting subjects (notably recurring and increasingly abrupt encounters with an ominous parka-clad figure). He’s haunted, too, but mostly by his memories of growing up with his rigid, borderline abusive and presently deceased father. That’s the hook on which Ghost Stories hangs its ghastly musings, the thing we expect the film to circle back to once Goodman completes his inquiries and renders his verdict on the authenticity of each incident. As an abstraction, that sounds like a stairway leading to Frank Capra levels of sentimentality: By wrestling with his skeptical biases, Goodman will confront his buried feelings about his dad and reconcile with his past. Maybe it’s for the best that the movie never goes there. —Andy Crump


21. The Field Guide to Evil (2018)
Directors: Ashim Ahluwalia, Can Evrenol, Severin Fiala, Veronika Franz, Katrin Gebbe, Calvin Reeder, Agnieszka Smoczynska, Peter Strickland, Yannia Veslemes

field-guide-to-evil-inset.jpg

The Field Guide to Evil can boast an attractive central conceit: It’s a set of eight tales all grafted together from lore and the campfire warnings of eras past, in locations all around the globe. It makes for a haltingly effective assembly of pastoral folk nightmares, unfortunately undone to some extent by its inconsistency. Still, there are properly unnerving sights here, as well as some beautifully cinematic ones. In Veronika Franz and Severin Fiala’s “The Sinful Women of Höllfall,” the Austrian countryside is itself a star, as the dark and morose short (which really describes this anthology as a whole) features some incredible forested scenes (benefiting greatly from superb location scouting) in offering a glimpse of a conservative society punishing aberrant attractions among the local youth. So too is Can Evrenol’s minimalist “Al Karisi” segment likely to stick in one’s mind, as a young woman fears her newborn child will be abducted by a Turkish childbirth demon. Shockingly brutal in spurts, in violence both overt and implied, the dread induced by “Al Karisi” feels very much like the product of the same mind that gave us Baskin. —Jim Vorel


20. XX (2017)
Directors: Roxanne Benjamin, Annie Clark, Karyn Kusama, Jovanka Vuckovic, Sofia Carrillo

xx-movie-inset.jpg

It’s important that the scariest segment in XX, Magnet Releasing’s women-helmed horror anthology film, is also its most elementary: Young people trek out into the wilderness for fun and recreation, young people incur the wrath of hostile forces, young people get dead, easy as you please. You’ve seen this movie before, whether in the form of a slasher, a creature feature, or an animal attack flick. You’re seeing it again in XX in part because the formula works, and in part because the segment in question, titled “Don’t Fall,” must be elementary to facilitate its sibling chapters, which tend to be anything but. XX stands apart from other horror films because it invites its audience to feel a range of emotions aside from just fright. You might, for example, feel heartache during Jovanka Vuckovic’s “The Box,” or the uncertainty of dread in Karyn Kusama’s “Her Only Living Son,” or nauseous puzzlement with Sofia Carrillo’s macabre, stop-motion wraparound piece, meant to function as a palate cleanser between courses (an effectively unnerving work, thanks to its impressive technical achievements). Most of all, you might have to bite your tongue to keep from laughing uncontrollably during the film’s best short, “The Birthday Party,” written and directed by Annie Clark, better known by some as St. Vincent, in her filmmaking debut. XX is a horror movie spoken with the voices of women, a necessary notice that women are revolutionizing the genre as much as men. —Andy Crump


19. Fear(s) of the Dark (2008)
Directors: Blutch, Charles Burns, Marie Caillou, Pierre di Sciullo, Lorenzo Mattotti, Richard McGuire

Animation tends to be underrepresented in the world of horror cinema; animated horror anthologies, even more so. The French Fear(s) of the Dark therefore stands out as a significant outlier, even before you factor in the choice to present all of its tales in different variations upon “black and white.” Visually, there’s nothing else quite like it: the five tales are moody and evocative, each one striking to behold, although they do tend to take their time in the telling. On the plus side, even if you can’t find a subtitled version, some of the segments have so little dialogue it barely matters, the film more of a visual tone poem on the ideas of “fear” and “darkness” than it is a collection of short stories. Its variety of animation styles is certainly a treat, ranging from dirty, smoky-looking charcoal and pencil sketching to crisp, black-and-white computer animation, conveyed in both two and three dimensions. A highlight is the segment directed by American cartoonist Charles Burns (of Black Hole), in which a man’s body is slowly corrupted by his girlfriend, who has become the host for a malevolent insect entity. As you might expect, it’s a bit on the gross side. —Jim Vorel


18. V/H/S (2012)
Directors: Adam Wingard, David Bruckner, Ti West, Glenn McQuaid, Joe Swanberg, Radio Silence

vhs-1-inset.jpg

Worth repeating: Horror anthologies are, by nature, almost always uneven in terms of quality, but if there’s one constant, it’s that fewer is better than many. That’s one of the factors that helps V/H/S work better than, say, the unrestrained insanity of The ABCs of Death. V/H/S also bears a more coherent framing narrative, featuring segments by some of the best young directors in horror, such as Adam Wingard and Ti West, but it’s ultimately David Bruckner, director of the genre-bending 2007 horror flick The Signal, who steals the show with “Amateur Night.” About a group of douchey guys who bring home a strange girl from the bar and get much more than they bargained for when she turns out to be a literal monster, the story eventually received a full-on feature film treatment under the title of Siren. As for which of the first two V/H/S entries is strongest, though, it’s a bit of a toss-up. Both of them have highlight segments, a few downers and are overally really entertaining. The one thing there’s no doubt about is that they’re much better than the abortive 2014 second sequel, V/H/S: Viral. —Jim Vorel


17. V/H/S/2 (2013)
Directors: Adam Wingard, Gareth Evans, Simon Barrett, Timo Tjahjanto, Jason Eisener, Eduardo Sánchez, Gregg Hale

vhs-2-inset.jpg

Your taste in the V/H/S series will likely depend on which entry has your personal favorite segment. At the very least, the second film contains what might be the single best segment in the entire series, Eduardo Sanchez’s “A Ride in the Park.” Without giving everything away: It involves bicyclists, zombies and helmet-mounted GoPro cameras, which help give us a perspective we’ve never really seen in horror while deftly avoiding the question of “Why would anyone be filming this?” There’s still some not-great segments—really the ideal V/H/S would be a compilation that takes only the best segments from each entry to create a really solid horror anthology. One has to wonder if Viral killed this series for good, or whether they’ll eventually act like it never happened and release a straight-up V/H/S/3 one of these days. —Jim Vorel


16. Tales from the Darkside: The Movie (1990)
Director: John Harrison

tales-from-the-darkside-movie-inset.jpg

The spiritual successor to the first two Creepshow films was the Tales from the Darkside feature film—also an anthology—even more ridiculous and zany than Creepshow. The highlight is probably “Cat From Hell,” a segment that was originally supposed to be featured in Creepshow 2 about a seemingly evil cat tormenting and stalking a wheelchair-bound old man to punish him for his past misdeeds. Although honestly, my favorite aspect of Tales from the Darkside: The Movie is the anthology framing story, which involves a child chained up in the kitchen of a witch who is planning on cooking him for dinner. Like a take on One Thousand and One Nights, the kid (Matthew Lawrence) plays Scheherazade and distracts the witch (the one and only Debbie Harry) by telling horror stories until he can engineer his escape. It’s like something from an overgrown episode of Are You Afraid of the Dark?. —Jim Vorel


15. Tales from the Crypt (1972)
Director: Freddie Francis

Modern horror fans can be forgiven if they associate the title Tales From the Crypt exclusively with the beloved 1990s HBO series that was the genesis point of so many horror careers, but the EC Comics series that inspired it (also including Vault of Horror and The Haunt of Fear) has itself been inspiring adaptations for quite a bit longer. Britain’s Amicus Horror Productions were a natural fit to take a crack at Tales from the Crypt in 1972, being a studio that specialized in horror anthologies, and although the comparatively lackluster Crypt Keeper will have you missing the more charming puppet host-to-come, the stories are bloody good fun. The stand-out, far and away, is “...And All Through the House,” in which a woman (Dame Joan Collins—that’s right) is terrorized by an escaped lunatic (Oliver MacGreavy), but can’t call the police … given that she just bumped off her own husband, minutes earlier, and has yet to dispose of the body. That killing is a stylishly executed murder, splashing blood across Hubby’s beloved newspaper, but what really makes the segment stand out is its Christmas Eve setting, lending it the hilariously macabre use of a number of radio Christmas carols while the action is unfolding. This may also be the first cinematic appearance of a “killer Santa Claus,” some 12 years before Silent Night, Deadly Night kicked off a small-scale moral panic in the U.S., which led to that film being pulled from theaters after only a week. Here? Nobody much seemed to care. —Jim Vorel


14. Tales of Terror (1962)
Director: Roger Corman

tales-of-terror-vincent-price.jpg

In the 1960s, B-movie producer extraordinaire Roger Corman set out on a mission to appropriate seemingly every Edgar Allan Poe story (and at least one H.P. Lovecraft one) that could be successfully adapted into a feature film that would turn a profit. This he did to great effect in flicks like House of Usher, Masque of the Red Death and The Pit and the Pendulum, but what of the stories too short for proper feature adaptations? That’s where this Poe horror anthology comes in. Corman has his way with the structure of these stories, reshaping them as he pleases, but they’re good fun thanks to the presence of Vincent Price in all three. Closer “The Facts in the Case of M. Valdemar” is a bit of a snooze, but middle chapter “The Black Cat” delights, pitting Price (as a snobbish aristocrat wine expert) against a career lush everyman played by Peter Lorre, who promptly runs circles around him in a competitive wine tasting. As you might have already guessed, “The Black Cat” is essentially an adaptation of Poe’s “The Cask of Amontillado,” to appropriately macabre results. —Jim Vorel


13. Body Bags (1993)
Directors:   John Carpenter, Tobe Hooper, Larry Sulkis

body-bags-1993-inset.jpg

Sometimes, even anthologies with less-than-stellar stories can get by on sheer charming commitment to gross-out delights, and that’s John Carpenter’s Body Bags for you. Originally conceived as a gorier, more grotesque spin on the Tales From the Crypt formula for Showtime, the series was cancelled after only a few potential episodes had been filmed. Not wanting to lose the material, Carpenter simply assembled his favorites into a feature film (that feels like it was meant to be a film all along). Each segment isn’t particularly memorable, except for the closer, which features Mark Hamill as a baseball player who loses an eye and then gains the eye of a serial killer via a donation. You can guess where things go from there. What is memorable about Body Bags is the goofy wraparound segments, which feature Carpenter himself as a Crypt Keeper-esque mortician who gleefully hacks apart bodies and drinks formaldehyde, showing a much lighter hearted personality than you’d expect from the director of dour films like The Thing or Prince of Darkness. It’s fun to watch Body Bags today for the not-so-subtle genre references (“Another grisly murder in Haddonfield today…”) and the incredible array of character actors and cameos that were lined up, including the likes of Wes Craven as a leering perv, Stacy Keach as a guy receiving miracle hair transplants, Charles Napier as a baseball manager, Twiggy as a housewife (reuniting these two from The Blues Brothers), Roger Corman as a doctor, Tom Arnold as a mortician and Sam Raimi as a corpse. —Jim Vorel


12. Creepshow 2 (1987)
Director: Michael Gornick

creepshow-2-inset.jpg

Creepshow 2 is very much a 1980s horror sequel: It attempts to largely replicate what audiences enjoyed about the first film iwithout mucking around too much with the formula, producing a good-but-not-quite-great effort in the process. Reducing the number of stories from five to three puts more weight on each individual entry; “Old Chief Wood’nhead” and “The Hitch-hiker” each have their moments, the first feeling like an HBO Tales from the Crypt episode and the latter like a Twilight Zone bit. It’s “The Raft” that is really worth the time here. One of Stephen King’s most simple stories makes for superb anthology content, with a premise that just can’t be beat: A group of teens are trapped on a raft in the middle of a lake, stalked by a blob-like creature that dissolves everything it touches, with spectacularly gory results. It’s like the 1980s remake of The Blob from Chuck Russell, simply cutting out backstory and subtext to focus on pure, primal action. Will the kids survive, or will they all be reduced to a pile of bones on the bottom of the lake? —Jim Vorel


11. Dr. Terror’s House of Horrors (1965)
Director: Freddie Francis

dr-terrors-house-of-horrors-inset.jpg

It’s hard not to fall in love with the Amicus Productions anthology Dr. Terror’s House of Horrors based on that glorious name alone. Come on—it’s amazing, full stop, with the rest just spooky icing on the creepy cake. Amicus is almost certainly the only film production company that has ever specialized specifically in horror anthologies, and Dr. Terror’s House of Horrors is particularly memorable for its framing device, in which a wonderfully costumed Peter Cushing (he looks so, so cool here), as “Dr. Terror,” deals out tarot cards to the other passengers of his train car, telling them how each will die. Those passengers include frequent Hammer collaborator Christopher Lee as a stuck-up art critic tormented by a disembodied hand belonging to an artist whose work he unfairly condemned, but each is engaging and moves along briskly. It soon becomes quite obvious where the wraparound story is going, but Dr. Terror’s House of Horrors is ultimately the exact sort of harmless fun that its title would imply. —Jim Vorel

Also in Movies